Best MyCase Alternatives for Law Firms (2025)
Compare top MyCase alternatives including Clio, PracticePanther, Smokeball, and ReadyDone. Honest pricing, features, and pros/cons for each.
MyCase ranks as a top legal practice management platform, with strong client portal features and competitive pricing. But it's not the right fit for every firm. This guide compares MyCase against its main competitors with honest assessments of each option.
Quick Comparison
| Software | Best For | Starting Price | Time Tracking | Full Practice Mgmt |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MyCase | Small firms, client communication | $39/user/mo | Manual + timers | Yes |
| Clio | Integration-heavy firms | $49/user/mo | Manual | Yes |
| PracticePanther | Simplicity-first firms | $49/user/mo | Manual + timers | Yes |
| Smokeball | Auto time tracking | $49/user/mo | Automatic | Yes |
| CosmoLex | Built-in accounting | $99/user/mo | Manual | Yes |
| Rocket Matter | Billing-focused | $65/user/mo | Manual + timers | Yes |
| ReadyDone | Zero-effort time tracking | $100/user/mo | Automatic + AI | No |
MyCase
Best for: Small to mid-size firms prioritizing client communication
MyCase excels at client-facing features. Its client portal is among the best in the industry, making it easy for clients to check case status, send messages, and access documents.
Pricing:
- Basic: $39/user/month
- Pro: $69/user/month
- Advanced: $89/user/month
ABA members receive discounts, making MyCase one of the more affordable options.
Pros:
- Excellent client portal and communication tools
- Clean, intuitive interface
- Strong document management
- Good mobile apps
- eSignature included in Pro tier
- Free migration assistance
Cons:
- Limited third-party integrations (40+ vs Clio's 200+)
- Reporting less customizable than competitors
- No built-in accounting
- Basic plan lacks key features (custom fields, intake, texting)
- Some users report recent price increases
Bottom line: MyCase delivers solid value for small firms focused on client communication. If you rely heavily on third-party integrations or need advanced reporting, look elsewhere.
Why Look for MyCase Alternatives?
MyCase works well for many firms. Common reasons attorneys explore alternatives:
- Integration needs: MyCase offers fewer integrations than Clio
- Reporting depth: Advanced analytics require higher tiers or external tools
- Accounting preferences: No built-in accounting means QuickBooks dependency
- Time tracking method: Manual timers don't capture everything
- Feature scope: Some features locked to higher-priced tiers
Practice Management Alternatives
Clio
Best for: Firms needing extensive integrations and enterprise features
Clio is the market leader with 150,000+ users and the largest integration ecosystem in legal tech.
Pricing:
- EasyStart: $49/user/month
- Essentials: $79/user/month
- Advanced: $109/user/month
- Complete: $149/user/month
Pros:
- 200+ integrations (more than any competitor)
- Strong mobile apps
- Excellent document management
- Large user community
- Regular feature updates
Cons:
- More expensive than MyCase at every tier
- Reports of declining support quality
- Complete tier needed for full CRM features
- No automatic time tracking
MyCase vs Clio: Choose Clio if you use many integrations. Choose MyCase if you prioritize client portal features and lower cost.
PracticePanther
Best for: Solo practitioners and small firms valuing simplicity
PracticePanther wins on ease of use. Most attorneys are productive within hours of setup.
Pricing:
- Solo: $49/user/month
- Essential: $69/user/month
- Business: $89/user/month
- Enterprise: $99/user/month
Pros:
- Extremely intuitive interface
- Fast onboarding
- Built-in payment processing (no extra fees)
- Two-way text messaging with clients
- Good workflow automation
Cons:
- Document automation locked to higher tiers
- Client portal less polished than MyCase
- Fewer integrations than Clio
MyCase vs PracticePanther: Both target similar firms. MyCase has a better client portal. PracticePanther is easier to learn and has better payment processing.
Smokeball
Best for: Firms wanting automatic time tracking built into practice management
Smokeball stands out with AutoTime, which captures time automatically as you work.
Pricing:
- Bill: $49/user/month
- Boost: $89/user/month
- Grow: Custom (includes AutoTime)
- Prosper+: Custom (includes AutoTime + AI)
Pros:
- Automatic time tracking (AutoTime) on higher tiers
- Strong document automation
- 200+ pre-built matter types
- 20,000+ court forms
- No data storage limits
Cons:
- AutoTime only on higher-priced tiers
- Primarily Windows-focused
- Pricing not transparent
- Complex initial setup
MyCase vs Smokeball: Choose Smokeball if automatic time tracking is a priority and you're on Windows. Choose MyCase for simpler setup and Mac compatibility.
CosmoLex
Best for: Firms wanting built-in legal accounting
CosmoLex eliminates the need for QuickBooks with integrated accounting, including trust accounting and IOLTA compliance.
Pricing:
- CosmoLex: $99/user/month
- CosmoLex Plus: $129/user/month
Pros:
- Full legal accounting built in
- Trust accounting with three-way reconciliation
- IOLTA compliance tracking
- Eliminates sync issues between systems
Cons:
- Higher starting price
- Steeper learning curve
- Fewer practice management features than competitors
MyCase vs CosmoLex: Choose CosmoLex if you handle client trust funds regularly. Choose MyCase if you prefer separate accounting software or don't need trust accounting.
Rocket Matter
Best for: Firms prioritizing billing accuracy and detailed time tracking
Rocket Matter started as a billing tool before expanding to full practice management. Billing remains its strength.
Pricing:
- Essentials: $65/user/month
- Pro: $85/user/month
- Premier: $99/user/month
Pros:
- Excellent time tracking with multiple timer options
- Strong pre-bill editing
- Detailed billing reports
- Chrome extension for quick capture
- Good matter budgeting
Cons:
- Higher starting price than MyCase
- Interface feels dated
- Mobile app less polished
- Document management not as strong
MyCase vs Rocket Matter: Choose Rocket Matter if billing accuracy is your top priority. Choose MyCase for better client communication and lower cost.
Time Tracking Alternatives
If your main issue with MyCase is time tracking, consider adding a specialized tool:
ReadyDone
Best for: Attorneys who forget to track time or want zero-effort capture
ReadyDone captures time automatically from screen activity and uses AI to identify billable work.
Pricing:
- $100/user/month or $1,000/year
Pros:
- Fully automatic time capture
- No timers to start or stop
- AI identifies billable work
- No behavior change required
- Complements existing practice management
Cons:
- Higher price than basic timers
- Not a full practice management replacement
- Newer to market than Laurel
MyCase + ReadyDone: Keep MyCase for practice management. Add ReadyDone for automatic time tracking. Export entries to MyCase for billing.
Timely
Best for: Budget-conscious automatic time tracking
Timely offers automatic time capture at a lower price point but lacks legal-specific features.
Pricing:
- Starter: $11/user/month (max 5 users)
- Premium: $20/user/month
- Unlimited: $28/user/month
Pros:
- Affordable
- Automatic tracking across apps
- Privacy-focused (no screenshots)
- Clean interface
Cons:
- Not built for legal
- No billing code suggestions
- Doesn't integrate with legal billing systems
- Mobile app less reliable
MyCase + Timely: An affordable combination if you can handle manual export and don't need legal-specific features.
How to Choose
By Firm Size
Solo practitioners: MyCase Basic or PracticePanther Solo provide good value. Add ReadyDone if time tracking is a pain point.
2-10 attorneys: MyCase Pro, PracticePanther Essential, or Smokeball. Consider integration needs and time tracking preferences.
10+ attorneys: Clio or Smokeball for scalability. CosmoLex if accounting integration matters.
By Priority
Client communication: MyCase excels here Integrations: Clio Simplicity: PracticePanther Automatic time tracking: Smokeball or ReadyDone Built-in accounting: CosmoLex Billing depth: Rocket Matter
By Budget
| Budget | Recommendation |
|---|---|
| Under $50/user | MyCase Basic, PracticePanther Solo |
| $50-80/user | MyCase Pro, Clio Essentials |
| $80-100/user | Smokeball Boost, CosmoLex |
| Willing to invest | Add ReadyDone for automatic time tracking |
Frequently Asked Questions
Is MyCase worth it?
For small firms prioritizing client communication and value, yes. The client portal is excellent. If you need extensive integrations or advanced reporting, consider alternatives.
Can I migrate from MyCase to another tool?
Yes. Most competitors offer migration assistance. Export contacts, matters, and documents. Budget 2-4 weeks for full transition. Some data requires manual transfer.
What's the best free alternative to MyCase?
True free options are limited. Clio offers a free tier with restrictions. For serious practice management, expect to pay. The lost billable time from poor tools costs more than software subscriptions.
Does MyCase have automatic time tracking?
No. MyCase offers manual time entry and timers. For automatic capture, pair MyCase with ReadyDone or switch to Smokeball.
Try ReadyDone Free
If manual time tracking is your main frustration with MyCase, ReadyDone captures time automatically. Keep using MyCase for practice management while recovering the billable hours you currently lose.
Start your free trial - No credit card required.
Related Resources:
- Best Clio Alternatives for Law Firms - Comparison of Clio vs competitors
- Best Timeslips Alternatives - Options for Sage Timeslips users
- How to Track Billable Hours Effectively - Best practices for time capture